Higher Rates Speed Life Insurance Reviews, Surrender Payouts Top 6 Trillion Yen

2026-07-29

Surrender payouts at life insurers are swelling.

Payouts hit record high in January-May

According to the Life Insurance Association of Japan, surrender payouts at 41 domestic life insurers totaled 6.019 trillion yen in January-May, up 39% from a year earlier. That was the highest for the period since 2020, which is as far back as the data can be traced. Since September 2025, monthly payouts have topped 1 trillion yen for nine straight months, and if that pace continues, January-June payouts are likely to exceed 7 trillion yen, also marking a record for the first half.

Customers move funds into investment trusts

Behind the trend is rising interest rates. Life insurers have raised assumed policy rates in response to higher yields on government bonds. The relative appeal of existing policies has weakened, prompting more customers to review their coverage.

In general, many policyholders switch to new contracts with higher assumed rates, but new contract sales in January-May rose just 1.2% from a year earlier to 26.9249 trillion yen, far less than the increase in surrender payouts. In some cases, policyholders are cancelling insurance contracts altogether and shifting funds into other financial products such as investment trusts and corporate bonds.

A woman in her 50s living in Osaka Prefecture said she cancelled a private pension insurance policy she had held for several years and invested in corporate bonds issued by a U.S. company. 'There is foreign exchange risk, but the 5% interest rate is attractive, and it is also effective as a way to manage retirement funds,' she said.

Insurers move to keep customers from leaving

Life insurance was originally centered on protection against illness, long-term care and death, with a clear division from investment products that carry the risk of principal loss. But recently, savings-type products that also serve an asset-building function have taken a larger share, making insurers more exposed to yield competition.

Takeki Fukuda, president of Financial Standard in Tokyo's Chiyoda ward, said more people are separating protection from savings, keeping protection through term insurance and savings through investment trusts. According to the Investment Trusts Association, net inflows into publicly offered equity funds, excluding ETFs, totaled 12.2867 trillion yen in January-June, up 52% from a year earlier. Fund inflows into strong-performing equity trusts have continued, supported by demand for the new NISA program.

Life insurers are also taking countermeasures. Fukoku Mutual Life Insurance is increasing dividends for policyholders who signed up before the assumed rate was raised, arguing for fairness in the burden borne by customers. Its cancellation lapse rate fell to 3.12% in fiscal 2025 from 3.39% the previous year.

Taiyo Life Insurance is gradually reducing the share of products sold through bank counters, where yield competition can easily intensify, and is instead selling savings-type products through its sales-agent channel. Masahiko Moriyama, president of parent company T&D Holdings, said sales agents have daily contact with customers, making it less likely that the sharp cancellations often seen in savings-type products will occur.

Restraining cancellations is a key management issue. To prepare for future insurance claims, life insurers mainly invest in super-long government bonds with maturities of more than 20 years. If cancellations rise more than expected, they would need to sell assets and turn them into cash in order to pay surrender payouts.

Rising interest rates have left super-long government bonds in an unrealized loss position below book value. If those losses are realized through sales, they could weigh on profits and limit management flexibility. There are also limits to raising assumed rates. That is because of the risk of negative spread, where investment returns fall below assumed rates. In the 1980s, some life insurers collapsed after excessive yield competition and the difficulty of managing assets following the bursting of the bubble economy.

Enjoyed this article? Share it with your network!